BreakPoint: French President Macron and African Babies

The Population Myth

Well, according to the French President, it’s no use pouring money into Africa because Africans have too many babies. Yes, he really said that.

Since his election in May, French President Emmanuel Macron has enjoyed the political equivalent of rock-star status. In June, the cover of the Economist depicted Macron walking on water with the caption “Europe’s Savior?”

But as the saying goes, “what goes up, must come down,” and recently Macron’s reputation has taken quite a hit. The reason? He publicly recycled one of the worst and most destructive ideas of recent history.

At the latest G-20 summit in Germany, a journalist from the Ivory Coast asked the French president why there was no African equivalent of the Marshall Plan, the U.S. aid program that helped to rebuild western Europe after World War II.

Macron’s reply was what called a “three-and-a-half-minute soliloquy,” in which he spoke about the differences between post-war Europe and modern Africa. He also referred to what he dubbed “civilizational problems” in Africa.

Having already jumped into the hot water, Macron then decided to turn up the temperature himself. Among those “civilizational problems,” he said, was that there were countries where women had 7 or 8 children, adding that you can pour billions of Euros into these places, and they would remain unstable.

Not surprisingly, the internet exploded in indignation. Chris Hayes of MSNBC called Macron’s speech “repugnant.” Laura Seay of Colby College wrote that it was “rich of a French President to criticize Africa this way.”

Now Seay’s reference, of course, was in light of France’s colonial past, and what the French called its “civilizing mission.” If she had stopped her critique there, she would have been fine. But she didn’t stop there.

Seay went on to blame, of all things, “the continuing influence of the Catholic Church.” She opined that “If contraception were widely available and the Catholic Church didn’t preach against it . . . we would likely see birth rates fall dramatically in Christianized parts of Francophone Africa.”

The problem with this is two-fold: First, the only African country with birth rates as high as Macron cited is Niger, an Islamic, not Catholic, country. The second highest is Somalia, another Islamic country.

The second problem is that Seay’s comments revealed that, at the end of the day, she and other liberal critics of Macron share his core conviction that high birthrates are a “civilizational problem.”

This conviction was at the heart of the 1968 book, “The Population Bomb,” by Paul Ehrlich, which began with the statement that “the battle to feed all of humanity is over” and predicted “an utter breakdown of the capacity of the planet to support humanity.”

Ehrlich’s predictions were proven wrong in every way imaginable, but it didn’t matter. In much of the world outside of Africa, the response was an aggressive attempt to reduce birthrates around the world that wound up working too well, especially in Europe.

The problem, as liberals like Phillip Longman and conservatives like Nicholas Eberstadt tell us, is not too many people but too few. Especially working-age, people. As the liberal Guardian newspaper put it, “Europe needs many more babies to avert a population disaster.” That’s why the Danish government ran that ad campaign that we told you about last year on BreakPoint, urging its citizens to “do it for Denmark.”

Obviously, Macron didn’t get the memo, or if he did, he chose instead to recycle a fifty-year-old bad idea that, in its most notorious implementation, China’s “one child policy,” “affected more people in a more intimate and brutal way” than any other government policy in history.

It’s an idea that threatens to leave countless people in the West “childless and alone” in their old age. An idea to which all of Africa, not just the French-speaking part, should reply, “non, merci.”


French President Macron and African Babies: The Population Myth

As John has often said, bad ideas have consequences–the population myth is is just one example.  Our response as Christians is to lovingly affirm God’s mandate for procreation, for the nurture and care of future generations.


Comment Policy: Commenters are welcome to argue all points of view, but they are asked to do it civilly and respectfully. Comments that call names, insult other people or groups, use profanity or obscenity, repeat the same points over and over, or make personal remarks about other commenters will be deleted. After multiple infractions, commenters may be banned.

  • ah.1960

    Two common themes dominate liberal thought:
    1) People are the problem. Too many people cause poverty, hunger, global warming, war, high healthcare costs… The answer is to get rid of people by encouraging contraception, abortion, limiting healthcare expenditures based on the government’s assessment of value/quality of life, doctor assisted suicide, etc.

    2) People (specifically other people) are not capable of taking care of themselves: People can’t/won’t provide healthcare for themselves so the federal government must mandate it for them. People can’t/won’t drive safely so the federal must mandate that they wear seatbelts. People can’t/won’t make wise financial decisions, so the federal government must control all financial transactions, especially mortgages and retirement funds. People can’t/won’t make the right decisions for the environment so the federal government must dictate how much water your toilet uses, encourage people to downsize their lifestyles/homes/expectations… (Interestingly, they always exempt themselves from the prescriptions they would force on the rest of us.)

  • Daniel S

    What Macron said is very sad. Population worldwide could decrease soon if countries like France continue having so few babies. As Christianity fades in the West, so does the command to “go forth and multiply.” However, if liberals like Macron have no children, France will be filled with Christians and especially Muslims.

  • Marg

    What he says is true tho! I’m no Liberal, but I don’t want Liberals producing any more than starving people having one after another children they can not provide food and health care for.! I also don’t want Africans reproducing just to watch 30% of the children die before the age of 5 from starvation! They have major starvation going on! It is too sad to watch!!

    • gladys1071

      I agree, but tell that to the pro-natalists that believe that people should reproduce no matter what. Watching children suffer from starvation is horrible , why would we want to bring more into this world.